Friday, June 2, 2023

California Today: Gavin Newsom on the “California effect”

Conor Dougherty of The New York Times spoke with the governor about leveraging California's market power to influence policies in other states.

It's Friday. Gov. Gavin Newsom talks about his push to expand the "California effect." Plus, how to best spend 36 hours in Los Angeles.

Gavin Newsom during the inauguration for his second term as California governor in January.Jim Wilson/The New York Times

Gov. Gavin Newsom is angry.

"I'm done being taken for granted," the California governor said in a recent interview. "It's time to get on offense."

Newsom had sat down with me back in March as part of a 45-minute interview to discuss the "California effect" for my article in the upcoming California issue of The New York Times Magazine. It's a phrase that academics use to describe the state's longstanding ability to drive national policy through the force of what's now the world's fifth-largest economy.

Now Newsom, a Democrat, is trying to create a whole new kind of California effect, one that goes far beyond environmental and consumer protection measures. He wants to leverage the state's market power to discourage corporations from acceding to policies in Republican states that he disagrees with.

He makes examples when it suits — as Walgreens learned when California said it would cancel a contract with the pharmacy chain in reaction to the company's decision not to sell the abortion pill mifepristone in several states.

In our latest interview, Newsom said that a tweet he posted on March 6 saying the state was "done" with Walgreens had actually been prompted by an unrelated issue. But he was unapologetic about wielding California's market power as a weapon in the nation's culture wars.

"I hope they realize the decisions they're making in these other states directly are going to start impacting them in states like California, in ways they haven't in the past," he said in a warning to corporate executives. "I want them to know that. I want every single one of them to know that."

The interview has been condensed and edited for clarity.

Conor Dougherty: I want to talk about this unique power California has, which is that its economy is so big it can effectively regulate the nation, at least in certain areas, based on its market size. Cars are the classic example, where California's tailpipe emission laws have made it a de facto regulator of the auto industry. I'm curious how you think about this lever, where it comes from, how you use it?

Gavin Newsom: I think, foundationally, it's moral authority.

CD: Sure, but Wyoming might believe they have moral authority. The problem is, 600,000-ish residents isn't enough scale.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

GN: It's the combination of both. We have no direct legal rights that we can assert in other states. But it's the very nature and scale of the state, larger than 21 states combined, together with unique capacity to lead, particularly in environmental space and the power of emulation.

CD: How much do you think to yourself, "How can I influence the entire nation?"

GN: More now than I've ever. I have deep anxiety about the moment we're living in. To see the attacks on the L.G.B.T.Q. community, see success with the "Don't Say Gay" bills; to see [Republicans] roll over corporate leaders again and again and again; to see them banning books, banning speech, intimidating not just teachers but librarians; to see what's happening with gun safety — you've got every governor tripping over each other to outdo one another, taking this playbook. That's why I think about it.

CD: The now-infamous Walgreens tweet, where you threatened to pull state contracts from the company after it said that it would not sell abortion drugs in certain states, felt like a new direction, where you're saying you want to use California's market power to wade into the culture wars.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

GN: I think you're right to observe that. But don't forget what we did with the right to private action, the quote-unquote "bounties" with guns. That was the first foray, in terms of shifting our approach to how we engage. That was when I thought: "All right, am I going to put out tweets and press releases? Am I just going to express my outrage by having a glass of wine watching Rachel Maddow every night? Or are we going to start using the power of the fifth- or fourth-largest economy to exercise ourselves more muscularly?"

I felt Walgreens needed to be called out. These guys are placating the right all across this country.

CD: When you say "these guys," you mean the corporations?

GN: All these corporations, they're silent. They're complicit in all this. They were all preaching something very differently just a few years ago. And they're completely silent now.

CD: Do you see the California economy and its huge market power as a weapon?

GN: I think it's an antidote. In the spirit of Reagan, it's a time for choosing. I'm serious about that. Which side are you on? You cannot have it both ways. And you know what, it's a pretty challenging dynamic. I'm very empathetic to corporate America right now. This is tough stuff. But then, just stop saying you care about your work force. Stop lying to folks.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

You saw what the College Board did on Black studies? They rolled over. You want to know why I did that to Walgreens? That was my blood boiling after the A.P. on Black studies, where the College Board completely capitulated.

CD: You're basically saying Walgreens became retribution for something the College Board did?

GN: I just meant this has to stop, and it needs to be called out. And I was calling it out with the College Board, but I didn't have any leverage. We were going to use our market power. Absolutely. It can't just be used on one side.

And here's the thing: This is not my natural state. This is not where I wish it would be. And the reality is, a rights regression and rollback is happening. And I can't sit back passively and dream of regretting. I've got three and a half years, and I'm not going to look back and regret that I did not meet this moment.

CD: What would you say to people who say that what the governor is doing here is wrong? That part of living in a pluralistic society is being OK with states doing things you don't like, and that trying to use the economy to influence it is inappropriate?

GN: I don't think it's inappropriate. These governors have the right to do what they're doing. They're exercising their right. We're exercising ours. It's not very complicated.

For more:

  • Read my full article in the The New York Times Magazine.

Conor Dougherty is an economics reporter for The New York Times, based in Los Angeles.

Enjoy all of The New York Times in one subscription — the original reporting and analysis, plus puzzles from Games, recipes from Cooking, product reviews from Wirecutter and sports journalism from The Athletic. Experience it all with a New York Times All Access subscription.

California schools may soon have to develop plans for cooling down outdoor areas, such as by planting more trees and replacing surfaces like asphalt that swelter on hot days.AP Photo/Jae C. Hong

The rest of the news

  • Beat the heat: The State Senate has passed a measure that would require schools to find ways to cool down outdoor play areas, such as replacing asphalt with green space, The Associated Press reports.
  • Fentanyl crisis: California legislators have advanced more than a dozen bills on the fentanyl crisis, including harsher penalties for dealers and more resources for prevention, The Associated Press reports.
  • Driverless trucks: State lawmakers argue that the Department of Motor Vehicles has mishandled the regulation of self-driving cars so badly that it can't be trusted to oversee autonomous trucks, The Los Angeles Times reports.
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
  • Nine-figure house club: Beyoncé and Jay-Z upgraded to a $200 million mansion in Malibu, joining a rarefied circle of celebrities who own residences worth $100 million or more.
  • Guns seized: A three-month operation led by federal law enforcement agents and the San Diego Police Department resulted in the seizure of 165 firearms, including 82 "ghost guns" that have no serial numbers, The Los Angeles Times reports.
  • Paying publishers: Californians might no longer be able to read news on Facebook or Instagram if the State Legislature passes a bill forcing tech platforms to pay publishers, The Los Angeles Times reports.
CENTRAL CALIFORNIA
  • A tale of two Fresnos: California's fifth-largest city has long been plagued by stark, intractable inequality. A new movement for environmental justice is working to change that.
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
  • Drug plant on the block: The Swiss pharmaceutical giant Roche announced plans to either sell its Vacaville manufacturing plant or shut it down by 2029, Reuters reports.
  • Zogg Fire charges dropped: A California judge dismissed all charges against Pacific Gas and Electric in connection with a 2020 wildfire ignited by its equipment that destroyed hundreds of homes and killed four people, The Associated Press reports.
Griffith Park in Los Angeles.Tanveer Badal for The New York Times

Where we're traveling

Tell us

We're approaching the midpoint of 2023. What are the best things that have happened to you so far this year? What have been your wins? Your unexpected joys, big or small?

Tell me at CAToday@nytimes.com. Please include your full name and the city where you live.

Santa Cruz Museum of Natural History

And before you go, some good news

A tourist spotted a gigantic fossilized tooth on a beach near Santa Cruz over Memorial Day weekend and posted a photo of it on social media.

Wayne Thompson, the paleontology collections adviser at the Santa Cruz Museum of Natural History, recognized that the tooth belonged to an ancient mastodon, a creature that became extinct 10,000 years ago, CBS News reports.

"This is (a) … molar tooth of the Pacific mastodon, Mammut pacificus, and an extremely important find," Thompson responded to the tourist's post. "Give me a call when you get a chance."

Thompson went to the beach himself to try to find the fossil, but it had vanished. It wasn't until the next day that a local jogger came across the tooth again on the same beach. He called the museum to report his discovery.

"I was so excited to get that call," Liz Broughton, a visitor experience manager at the museum, said in a statement.

Thanks for reading. We'll be back on Monday. Enjoy your weekend.

Soumya Karlamangla, Briana Scalia and Johnna Margalotti contributed to California Today. You can reach the team at CAtoday@nytimes.com.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for California Today from The New York Times.

To stop receiving California Today, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

facebooktwitterinstagram

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018

No comments:

Post a Comment